Ajoutez votre titre ici

Trust is less expensive than control

It’s fascinating what our new game, ReSet, brings to light – in such a simple, smooth and non-confrontational way!

 

Act 1, Scene 1


A few months ago, we ran a ReSet workshop with one of our long-standing clients, a group that is well established in France and is expanding internationally. One of the teams drew a card based on Principle 3 of our 6 Principles of Regeneration model (“Reduce attacks on life”), which asked them to give examples in response to the following question:

 

‘What beliefs do we hold about our customers and suppliers that might limit regeneration?’

 

One participant’s expression gave him away: he clearly had an idea, but you could sense he was hesitant to share it. Encouraged by his teammates (and all of us around the table!), he finally said: ‘Actually, I think we don’t trust our suppliers…’.

Asked to elaborate, he explains how, in the 20 years he has worked at this company, supplier control processes have steadily increased, reinforcing the need for ever more extensive administrative monitoring.

“And what does that have to do with regeneration?” his colleagues asked. “Well,” he replied, “on the one hand, with all this energy invested in control processes, forms to fill in, and so on, we have less time or energy to devote to anything else.” And from the supplier’s perspective, these procedural hurdles that have crept into the relationship have turned it into something purely transactional, a far cry from the original co-creative partnership, gradually stifling any desire to take bold steps in innovation.

 

A few rounds later, another team draws a card, this time based on Principle 1 of the model: “Divest from life-draining processes and relationships”. The card asks them:

 

‘Which objectives no longer help us to generate real added value, and that we should get rid of?’

 

Referring to the control processes mentioned by the other team, one person pipes up: “I think we should shut down our in-house travel agency service and instead trust our staff and suppliers to organise themselves within a budget we set for them. Our current system, rather than helping us keep costs under control, is costing us a fortune!”

 

******

 

Act 1, scene 2

 

The ReSet workshop includes a dedicated ‘play’ session, the aim of which is to generate as many regenerative ideas for the company as possible, without holding back or censoring oneself. In terms of creativity, we are in the divergent phase, like an inverted funnel: we generate as many ideas as possible; those around the table do not need to agree on anything – we’ll sort through them later.

At the end of this game phase, which lasts between 1 hour and 1 hour 30 minutes, participants are invited to take a step back and begin sorting through the suggestions made during the game. This marks the start of an initial attempt at convergence, whilst the ideas are still fresh.

 

Using a matrix we provide, the participants review everything they have proposed, and this time the idea of an in-house travel agency catches the attention of many people. Come to think of it, why did we set up this system in the first place? Because it’s true that it’s very cumbersome and doesn’t really work very well…

*****

 

Act 1, scene 3

 

Three weeks later, we meet up again with our clients for the ReSet workshop to finalise with them the roadmap they wish to adopt, based on the outcomes of the workshop. This is the convergence phase, undertaken with a clear head, allowing time for reflection, consideration and discernment.

Among the key topics, those of agility, responsiveness and efficiency frequently recur. And, to make concrete progress in this direction, our client would like us to help them accurately assess their in-house travel agency: its original purpose, its advantages, its limitations, and what avenues for transformation might enable it to operate with greater agility, responsiveness and efficiency.

*****

 

Act 2, scene 1

 

Together with our client, we set up an internal working group, rooted in the organisational culture and therefore better placed to understand the dynamics, historical issues and the acceptability of potential changes.

It soon became clear that the in-house travel agency was relatively new (less than 10 years old) and had been set up to address two problems at the time:

  1. International growth, which was a cause for concern as the volume of travel was set to increase
  2. Two or three incidents (occurring in quick succession) involving suppliers who had submitted rather ‘hefty’ expense claims, comprising business-class flights and hotels that were a little too luxurious

The response at the time was therefore focused on control: controlling the exponential volume of travel; and controlling expenditure on supplier expenses.

At the time, one person had been recruited to manage this agency, reporting to the HR Director. However, since then, another person has had to be recruited, such had been the increase in the volume of travel, and with it the workload involved in each booking: identifying options, obtaining approval from the traveller, purchasing tickets and making hotel bookings, providing after-sales support to travellers, and so on.

 

The benefits of this approach centred on one key factor: the ease of assessing travel costs. With just a few clicks, the head of the in-house agency could tell the working group how many people had travelled, at what average rate, what the overall budget managed by the agency was, and the monthly, quarterly and annual trends.

To our surprise – and above all to that of the travel agency manager – the expected time savings for travellers did not prove to be a benefit for them; quite the opposite, in fact: the process itself took them far longer than if they had made their own bookings. Why? Because this process required several rounds of communication with the travel agency, whereas travellers could arrange their trips in a single visit to their usual websites.

 

The limitations of the model became apparent quite quickly: in addition to the extra time it took (where a time saving had been anticipated), the cost of the trips themselves increased, to an average of almost 400 €, whereas the average price of a trip booked directly by the traveller is 200 € to 250 €. The reasons for this are linked to the time that elapses between the traveller stating their requirements and the ticket actually being purchased (on average 6 to 8 days), against a backdrop of dynamic pricing by market operators, which means that ticket prices – initially cheaper – continue to rise the closer one gets to the travel date. It should be noted that this average price does not even include a share of the agency’s operating costs (salaries, office costs, etc.).

Another limitation of the model is that the agency has ‘macro’ information about the trip (departure city, destination city, number of nights’ accommodation), whereas the traveller has ‘micro’ information that makes all the difference: meeting point, ease of access, which times to avoid, etc. Our experience has shown just how much failing to take these details into account – apart from the inconvenience it causes – also leads to additional costs, particularly for taxis.

 

Act 2, scene 2

When the working group presented these findings to them, our clients did not take long to make a decision. They chose to put an end to this process, which was no longer working and was costing him a great deal of money.

Instead, he introduced a tiered pricing system for his employees and suppliers regarding travel, with department managers responsible for the relevant travel arrangements overseeing its implementation. He redeployed one of the agency’s staff to a different role, leaving the person originally recruited to work part-time as the travel coordinator – but only to deal with situations not covered by the tiered pricing system – whilst also redeploying her part-time to another role.

The company has shifted from an approach based on control to one based on trust and subsidiarity, whilst adding a genuine support service.

 

*****

 

Act 3 : key learnings

What are the takeaways from all this process?

 

  1. Trust costs less than control: in seeking to prevent excessive expense claims, the company – to paraphrase Isaac Getz – had chosen to ‘manage for the 3 per cent’: it sets rules designed to curb the behaviour of 3 per cent of staff, but expects the remaining 97 per cent to follow them. However, in this case at least, the solution turns out to be far more costly than the expenses it was intended to avoid.
  2. Organisational layers are costly: as soon as a new role or a new level is introduced, it entails additional infrastructure and operational costs, which must be carefully assessed before embarking on the creation of such layers.
  3. Innovate based on the emerging future, not on the logic of the past: a travel agency is a very 20th-century model, which provided significant added value at the time. Today, thanks to numerous apps, booking has been digitalised and made accessible to all; everyone is used to organising their own trips, finding ‘great deals’ and tailoring them to their preferences. This trend was already evident 10 years ago, when the company opted for an in-house travel agency – a choice rooted in the logic of the past, rather than (to paraphrase Otto Scharmer this time) the challenge of innovating based on the emerging future
  4. Nature is built on subsidiarity – let’s emulate it! Indeed, centralisation does not exist in Nature; decisions and actions are taken as close as possible to where they are experienced. This is what makes natural systems efficient, agile and resilient. At our client’s organisation, if the in-house travel agency were to cease operating, everyone would be paralysed – whereas, in a decentralised setup, if one or two people have difficulty booking their trip, this does not prevent the rest of the travellers from carrying on with their activities. The in-house travel agency runs counter to a key principle of permaculture, which reminds us that each function must be performed by several elements in order to build resilience right from the design stage; whereas here, for one function (travel), we had only a single element (the agency).

Leave a Reply

Also worth reading

Search

Categories

Stay connected

Subscribe to our newsletter to be notified of the publication of our articles.
We were unable to confirm your registration.
THANKS ! Your registration must be confirmed by email...